Eyebrow pencils and eyeliners are both staples in many makeup routines, but can they be used interchangeably? This is a common question for those looking to maximize their beauty products. While it may seem convenient to use an eyebrow pencil as an eyeliner, there are essential factors to consider, such as formulation, pigmentation, and safety. This guide will cover everything you need to know, including the pros, cons, and best practices for using an eyebrow pencil as an eyeliner.
Key Differences Between Eyebrow Pencils and Eyeliners
To understand whether an eyebrow pencil can be used as an eyeliner, let’s examine the differences between the two products:
| Feature | Eyebrow Pencil | Eyeliner |
| Formula | Drier, wax-based for brow hold | Creamier, designed for smooth application |
| Pigmentation | More muted, natural colors | Richer pigments, intense definition |
| Texture | Firmer, meant for precise strokes | Softer for easy gliding |
| Longevity | Designed for all-day hold on brows | Formulated to resist smudging or fading |
| Skin Sensitivity | Safe for brows but not always tested for delicate eyelid skin | Ophthalmologist-tested for eye safety |
Can You Use an Eyebrow Pencil as Eyeliner?
Yes, But With Some Considerations
Using an eyebrow pencil as an eyeliner is possible, but it depends on the product’s formulation and your skin’s sensitivity. Here are the pros and cons:
Pros:
- Multipurpose Use: Saves money and minimizes the need for extra products.
- Soft & Natural Look: Provides a more subtle effect compared to traditional eyeliner.
- Matte Finish: Works well for those who prefer a non-shiny eyeliner look.
- Long-Wearing: Eyebrow pencils are designed for durability, reducing the need for frequent touch-ups.
Cons:
- Harder Application: Brow pencils are not as creamy as eyeliners, making application on the delicate eyelid trickier.
- Limited Color Range: Most eyebrow pencils come in brown or taupe shades, limiting bold eyeliner options.
- Not Ophthalmologist-Tested: Some formulas may cause irritation if applied too close to the waterline.
How to Safely Use an Eyebrow Pencil as an Eyeliner
If you decide to use an eyebrow pencil as an eyeliner, follow these steps to ensure safe and effective application:
- Choose the Right Eyebrow Pencil: Opt for one with a smooth, blendable formula rather than a stiff, waxy one.
- Sharpen the Pencil: A sharp tip allows for precise application and prevents tugging on the eyelid.
- Apply with Gentle Strokes: Lightly draw along the lash line, building up intensity gradually.
- Blend for a Softer Look: Use a smudging brush or cotton swab to soften harsh lines.
- Set with Eyeshadow or Powder: To enhance longevity, set the liner with a matching eyeshadow.
- Avoid the Waterline: Unless the product is specifically tested for eye use, avoid applying it directly to the waterline to prevent irritation.
Best Eyebrow Pencils That Can Double as Eyeliner
Not all eyebrow pencils work well as eyeliners. Here are some highly rated options known for their smooth texture:
| Brand | Product Name | Features |
| Anastasia Beverly Hills | Brow Wiz | Ultra-fine tip, blendable formula |
| NYX | Micro Brow Pencil | Soft application, affordable |
| Benefit | Precisely, My Brow Pencil | Waterproof, smooth texture |
| Maybelline | Total Temptation Brow Definer | Creamy consistency, easy to apply |
Alternative Multi-Use Makeup Products
If you’re looking for versatile makeup options, consider these products:
- Gel Eyeliners – Can double as brow pomades when applied with a light hand.
- Cream Eyeshadows – Work as both an eyeshadow base and eyeliner.
- Kohl Pencils – Softer than traditional eyeliners, making them easier to blend as brow fillers.
Conclusion
Yes, you can use an eyebrow pencil as an eyeliner, but with some precautions. While it provides a natural, matte look, it may not glide as smoothly or last as long as a dedicated eyeliner. Always check the ingredients and perform a patch test if you have sensitive skin. If versatility is a priority, choosing a multipurpose brow pencil can be a smart addition to your makeup routine.
Would you try using an eyebrow pencil as eyeliner? Let us know your thoughts!